Illustrative, not a real customer. The form is invented; the review format is what members get.
Attached: signup-form.png. People start this and don't finish.
- UX review, done
- interaction & forms, done
- accessibility, done
- content design, done
- UX research, done
Mock signup form with 12 fields in two columns, placeholder-only labels, a distorted-text CAPTCHA and a small grey Submit button.
All seven fixes applied.
Three fixes matter most. Here's the principle behind each, and how you'll know it worked.
Fix first
Fix 1.
Critical (4).12 fields up front, including company size, phone, a 14-option role dropdown and "How did you hear about us?"
Ask for email and password only. Ask role and company size after signup.
Principles:- Hick's law
- progressive disclosure
- ask only what the task needs
Fix 2.
Critical (4).Placeholder text used as labels, in two columns. The labels vanish as you type.
Put visible labels above each field, in one column.
Principles:- WCAG 3.3.2 Labels or Instructions
- single-column form guidance
Fix 3.
Critical (4).Errors appear all at once at the top, saying only "Invalid input."
Check each field when people leave it, and put the error next to the field with how to fix it.
Principles:- Nielsen heuristic 9
- WCAG 3.3.1 Error Identification
- WCAG 3.3.3 Error Suggestion
The ranking is an expert review. A five-person usability test would confirm the order.
What to measure after
- Primary:
Start-to-complete rate, and drop-off by field
Validation errors per submit
Time to complete
A five-person usability test, with the SEQ after the task
Guardrail: trial-to-activation shouldn't fall. It tells you asking less up front didn't bring in worse signups.